dir. James L. Brooks
As Good as It Gets isn’t about transformation so much as erosion—watching someone wear down just enough to let another person in. On paper, it’s a romantic comedy. In practice, it’s closer to a barbed character piece—one that slips between cringe and sentiment without ever settling into either. Jack Nicholson plays Melvin Udall, a man so proudly unpleasant he treats decency like a flaw. Racist, sexist, homophobic, and compulsively regimented, he barrels through the world offending everyone in his path. And yet it’s compulsively watchable. Melvin has obsessive-compulsive disorder, though that’s just one part of the obstacle course. He eats breakfast at the same diner, at the same table, served by the same waitress—Carol (Helen Hunt), the only person willing to engage with him at all, let alone refill his coffee. He’s clearly infatuated, but too emotionally mangled to express it without accidentally insulting her mid-sentence. She endures it, barely. Across the hall from Melvin’s apartment is Simon (Greg Kinnear), a soft-spoken gay artist who receives the full force of Melvin’s bile until a string of events leaves him hospitalized. That’s when Melvin ends up taking care of Simon’s dog—the same one he once shoved down a garbage chute. And something changes. Not through confession or breakthrough, but through routine. Feed the dog. Walk the dog. Let a few of the walls crack. The film doesn’t chase redemption. Melvin stays difficult. He improves, reluctantly, and only as much as he absolutely has to. Nicholson is sharp as ever, but it’s in his interactions—brittle, biting, occasionally disarmed—that the film finds its rhythm. Hunt, in an Oscar-winning role, brings a kind of tired defiance to Carol that makes her believable as someone who knows better but chooses hope anyway. Kinnear is quietly affecting, and Cuba Gooding Jr., as Simon’s no-nonsense art dealer, delivers every line like he’s ready to drag the movie back to earth when it floats too high. It’s funny, sharp, awkward, sometimes even moving.
Starring: Jack Nicholson, Helen Hunt, Greg Kinnear, Cuba Gooding Jr., Skeet Ulrich, Shirley Knight, Yeardley Smith.
Rated PG-13. TriStar Pictures. USA. 139 mins.