dir. Jim Abrahams
Twin girls are born. Twice. In side-by-side hospital rooms. A nurse with the instincts of a hay bale swaps one from each set, possibly mid-yawn, and forty years later, capitalism brings them back together—two Bette Midlers, two Lily Tomlins, and one Manhattan skyscraper full of mistaken identity and property disputes. It’s a premise built for ricochet—misidentifications, hallway collisions, two Midlers shouting across a hotel lobby—but the gags are slow on their feet, clumsily timed and staged like they’re waiting for clearer instructions. There’s an attempt at farce, or at least the bones of one: shouting through doors, missed cues, characters entering frame with an expression that announces, “I am confused.” A late-game homage to Duck Soup’s mirror routine materializes, under-rehearsed and over-lit, as though the director asked for it by name and hoped no one would notice the timing was off by several beats. Tomlin, miraculously, carves out two characters who share only a haircut. One smiles like it hurts; the other blinks at city life like it’s been misfiled. Midler’s approach is broader—less duality, more double occupancy. She plays to the rafters, even when there are no rafters, just boardrooms and hotel lobbies with room for volume. The whole thing moves like it’s wearing heels a size too small: tottering, repetitive, and too focused on entrances to bother with punchlines. Setups circle back like bad improv, each scene trying to top the last with louder misunderstandings and longer delays. The climax, which should be a comic pileup, arrives with the energy of a scheduling conflict—everyone shows up, no one knows why, and the film just sort of files out.
Starring: Bette Midler, Lily Tomlin, Fred Ward, Edward Herrmann, Michele Placido, Daniel Gerroll, Barry Primus, Michael Gross, Nicolas Coster, Seth Green.
Rated PG. Touchstone Pictures. USA. 97 mins.