dir. Molly Gordon, Nick Lieberman
Theater Camp isn’t Waiting for Guffman, but it gets close enough to live in the same drawer. It’s a mockumentary with just enough barbed affection to dodge condescension and just enough structure to keep the bits from drifting into sketch territory. Set in a run-down summer camp devoted entirely to musical theater, the film treats jazz hands as a second language and minor vocal trauma as a career setback. The kids take it seriously. The counselors take it religiously. Every warm-up is sacred, every spotlight a birthright. And this year’s centerpiece production—an original musical honoring the camp’s founder (Amy Sedaris), now tragically in a coma—becomes the sort of meta train wreck only theater people would attempt with a straight face. The show is a perfect joke, built entirely from earnestness and delusion. Some of the other material doesn’t hold quite as well. There are inspired one-liners and extended gags that hit, but they’re interspersed with stretches that feel more like filler than buildup. A “let’s save the camp” subplot creeps in to add stakes nobody asked for. It’s not terrible—it’s just when the movie starts to feel a little generic. But when Theater Camp sticks to what it knows—picking apart the language of overzealous performers and the unintentional comedy of backstage ego management—it settles into something that works. The cast, many of whom have been through this world or at least survived a few callbacks, nail the small stuff: the clenched smiles, the teary self-discoveries, the group hugs that somehow still feel like competitions. This movie doesn’t always sing, but it stays on key. If you’ve ever cried over a call sheet or watched someone warm up for an off-book table read, this knows exactly who you are.
Starring: Molly Gordon, Ben Platt, Noah Galvin, Jimmy Tatro, Patti Harrison, Nathan Lee Graham, Ayo Edebiri.
Rated PG-13. Searchlight Pictures. USA. 94 mins.