dir. Joseph L. Mankiewicz
An overstuffed bauble of a mystery, The Honey Pot plays like someone gave a whodunit a Venetian vacation and told it to luxuriate. Rex Harrison stars as Cecil Fox, a wealthy eccentric with too much time, too many servants, and one idea: fake his death to lure in three ex-lovers and watch them squirm for inheritance. The setup is cribbed from Volpone, but with the gender flipped, the satire thinned out, and the tension replaced by high-thread-count mischief. The guests arrive like characters from competing films: Dominique (Capucine), a broke princess with icy restraint; Merle (Edie Adams), a fading screen star still chasing spotlight; and Lone Star Crockett (Susan Hayward), a Texan tycoon with legal paperwork and a tongue sharp enough to draw blood. Lone Star claims to be Fox’s common-law wife. She also ends up dead. Enter Maggie Smith as her nurse—prim, observant, and slowly realizing she’s the only one in the room with both a conscience and a clue. There’s pleasure in the details: the rustle of expensive fabrics, the glint of chandeliers, Rex Harrison pirouetting through the plot like he’s auditioning for operetta. But the mystery folds in on itself until resolution feels beside the point. It’s not so much solved as set aside. What begins as a darkly comic puzzle turns metaphysical, then opaque. The film mistakes convolution for cleverness and mood for meaning. Still, the performances are crisp, and Maggie Smith walks away with the movie in her handbag.
Starring: Rex Harrison, Maggie Smith, Cliff Robertson, Susan Hayward, Capucine, Edie Adams.
Not Rated. 20th Century Fox. UK-Italy. 132 mins.