dir. Woody Allen
Stardust Memories doesn’t so much pay tribute to 8½ as try to crawl inside it, unzip it, and wear it like a costume. Stardust Memories is less a riff on Fellini than a nervous breakdown in black-and-white—a self-loathing valentine to the art of making movies, or maybe just to the feeling of being misunderstood by people who paid to love you. Allen plays Sandy Bates, a successful filmmaker best known for light comedies, now straining to make something more “serious.” His latest project—an experimental film set on a train, full of melancholy and metaphors—isn’t going over well with the studio. “Too depressing,” they tell him. “Too honest,” he says back. Meanwhile, he’s trapped at a seaside retrospective of his own work, dodging autograph hounds, sycophants, and wide-eyed fans who mostly want him to repeat the funny lines from the early stuff. The camera gets swarmed by these faces—lumpy, eager, cracked like character studies carved from deli meat—pressing in like they’re trying to crawl into the frame. The jokes come in glimmers. Some are clever, a few land, most pass by like old neighbors you don’t really miss. The rhythm is fractured, the tone unsure, and the relationship throughline—between Sandy and Dorrie (Charlotte Rampling), a fragile ex whose mental health declined during their time together—is too underfed to register as a true emotional anchor. Allen denies it’s autobiographical, but there’s little distance between the man on screen and the one behind the camera. Stardust Memories is adored by some of Allen’s most devoted fans. He claims it’s among his best. But it doesn’t invite you in—it waves from a locked room, hoping you’ll mistake alienation for profundity. I didn’t.
Starring: Woody Allen, Charlotte Rampling, Jessica Harper, Marie-Christine Barrault, Tony Roberts, Daniel Stern, Amy Wright, Helen Hanft.
Rated PG. United Artists. USA. 89 mins.